Founders, early employees, and investors in private companies can hold significant wealth on paper with few ways to access it. Selling may be restricted or may mean giving up future upside. Borrowing against the shares is another approach some shareholders explore.
Loans backed by private company stock exist, but they differ in important ways from a traditional securities-based line of credit on publicly traded stock. This guide explains how these arrangements generally work, what they cost, and the questions to ask before considering one.
Why Shareholders Look at Borrowing
People consider borrowing against private stock for several reasons:
Funding an option exercise: Paying the exercise price and related taxes without selling other assets.
Covering a tax bill: Paying taxes owed on vested equity or an option exercise.
Major purchases: Buying a home or funding other large expenses.
Diversification: Accessing cash to invest elsewhere while keeping the shares.
Avoiding a sale: Holding shares through a potential IPO or acquisition rather than selling at a discount today.
How Private Stock Loans Generally Work
Collateral
The borrower pledges private company shares, or in some cases vested options, as collateral. Because private shares are illiquid and hard to value, lenders usually lend only a modest percentage of the estimated value.
Recourse and Non-Recourse Structures
Recourse loans: The borrower is personally responsible for repayment beyond the collateral.
Non-recourse loans: The lender's claim is generally limited to the pledged shares. If the shares lose value, the borrower may walk away from the loan and the shares, but pricing tends to reflect that added risk for the lender.
Repayment Terms
Private stock loans are commonly structured to be repaid when a liquidity event occurs, such as an IPO, acquisition, or tender offer. Some include a maturity date by which the loan must be repaid even if no event has happened.
Pricing
Costs can include interest, origination fees, and in some structures a share of the upside in the stock. Interest may accrue rather than be paid currently, increasing the amount owed over time.
Company Rules to Check First
Private companies often restrict what shareholders can do with their stock.
Pledging restrictions: Some stock plans and bylaws prohibit pledging shares as collateral.
Transfer restrictions and rights of first refusal: These can affect how a lender could take or sell the shares.
Insider trading policies: If the company goes public, policies may limit pledging or hedging by employees and directors.
Consent requirements: Some arrangements require approval from the company.
Reading your equity documents and confirming the rules with company counsel can help avoid problems later.
Risks to Understand
Value can fall: If the company's value declines, a recourse borrower may owe more than the shares are worth.
Timing uncertainty: A liquidity event may take longer than expected, while interest accrues.
Cost of upside sharing: Structures that give the lender part of the gain can reduce what you keep if the company does well.
Concentration: Borrowing against a single company's stock keeps your financial outcome tied to that company.
Personal liability: Recourse loans can put other assets at risk.
Tax Considerations
In general, borrowing money is not a taxable event, so taking a loan secured by stock does not by itself trigger capital gains tax. However, some arrangements that look like loans can be treated as a sale for tax purposes, depending on how much of the risk and reward of the shares passes to the lender. Prepaid forward contracts and similar structures may raise these questions. Interest deductibility also depends on how the loan proceeds are used. These are areas to review carefully with a CPA or tax attorney before signing.
If loan proceeds are used to exercise options, the exercise itself can have tax consequences. Nonqualified stock option exercises generally create ordinary income, and incentive stock option exercises may affect the alternative minimum tax.
Comparing Borrowing With Selling
A simple comparison can clarify the tradeoff. Selling a portion of shares in a tender offer turns part of the position into cash now, generally with tax due on any gain, and reduces exposure to the company. Borrowing keeps the full position, delays any tax on a sale, and preserves potential upside, but adds interest, fees, and repayment risk, and leaves your financial outcome concentrated in one company. Some shareholders combine the two, selling a portion and borrowing modestly against the rest. Laying out the costs side by side over a realistic time frame can make the comparison clearer.
Borrowing Against Public Stock Is Different
Once shares are publicly traded and freely tradable, borrowing options broaden. Securities-based lines of credit and margin loans generally lend against diversified portfolios or public stock, with daily valuation and the possibility of collateral calls if values fall. Concentrated public positions may face lower borrowing limits, and company policies may still restrict pledging by insiders.
Alternatives to Borrowing
Tender offers: Selling a portion of shares when the company or investors offer to buy.
Secondary sales: Selling shares to an outside investor, if the company permits it.
Exercise financing: Arrangements that fund exercise costs in exchange for part of future proceeds.
Gradual exercise: Exercising options over time to manage cost and tax.
Waiting: Holding until a liquidity event, accepting the timing uncertainty.
Each path has different costs, risks, and tax effects, and they can be combined.
Questions to Ask Before Borrowing
What do my company documents allow? Confirm whether pledging is permitted.
Is the loan recourse or non-recourse? Understand what happens if the shares lose value.
What is the total cost? Include interest, fees, and any upside sharing over a realistic time frame.
When must it be repaid? Know the maturity date and what happens if no liquidity event occurs.
How is it taxed? Ask your tax professional whether the structure could be treated as a sale.
How does it fit my broader plan? Consider how the loan affects your overall debt, cash flow, and concentration.
How Auric Evaluates Borrowing Decisions
Auric Capital Partners' liability management work focuses on evaluating how debt and leverage fit into a client's broader plan, and its monetizing strategies aim to help identify opportunities to convert illiquid assets into accessible capital. The firm also works on restricted and non-restricted stock strategies and concentrated stock positions, which often go hand in hand with private company equity.
For founders, executives, and early employees, those conversations are coordinated with the client's CPA and legal counsel, who review loan documents and tax treatment. Learn more about the team.
Get Started
If much of your wealth is tied up in private company stock and you are weighing whether to borrow, sell, or wait, we can help you organize the tradeoffs. Contact Auric Capital Partners to begin.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can you borrow against private company stock?
Some specialized lenders offer loans secured by private company shares. Availability depends on the company, the shares, and whether company documents allow pledging.
Is a loan against private stock taxable?
Borrowing is generally not a taxable event. However, some structures that transfer much of the risk and reward of the shares to the lender may be treated as a sale. A tax professional can review the terms.
What is a non-recourse stock loan?
In a non-recourse loan, the lender's claim is generally limited to the pledged shares. If the shares lose value, the borrower is typically not personally liable for the shortfall, though costs are often higher.
How much can you borrow against private shares?
Lenders usually lend a modest percentage of the estimated value because private shares are illiquid and difficult to value. Terms vary by lender and company.
What happens if the company does not go public?
Loan terms usually specify a maturity date. If no liquidity event occurs, the borrower may need to repay from other assets or, in a non-recourse loan, the lender may take the shares.
This content is for educational and informational purposes only and should not be considered investment, tax, or legal advice. It is not a recommendation to buy or sell any security or to adopt any particular investment strategy. Investing involves risk, including the possible loss of principal. Past performance is no guarantee of future results, and no strategy can guarantee a profit or protect against loss. Please consult with a qualified professional about your individual situation. Registered Representative of Sanctuary Securities Inc. and Investment Advisor Representative of Sanctuary Advisors, LLC. Securities offered through Sanctuary Securities, Inc., Member FINRA, SIPC. Advisory services offered through Sanctuary Advisors, LLC., a SEC Registered Investment Adviser. Auric Capital Partners is a DBA of Sanctuary Securities, Inc. and Sanctuary Advisors, LLC.




